Tu je EN preklad 1:1, so zvýraznenými iba modrými časťami zo screenshotu:

How to Design a Magnetic Application Correctly from the Specification

The first step is to define the function of the application precisely. A magnet for clamping during machining is designed differently, a metal particle separator differently, a handling element for sheet metal differently, and magnetic closing or positioning differently. The same magnet material may be suitable in several cases, but the working situation is decisive, not the catalog name.

It is important to distinguish between static and dynamic loads. If the magnet holds a part without movement in a stable position, the design may be based on different reserves than in an application where impacts, vibrations, acceleration, or lateral forces are present. Manufacturing operations often underestimate shear stress in particular. A magnet may have a high perpendicular holding force, but if the part tries to move along the surface, friction, the quality of the contact surface, and mechanical guidance become decisive.

It is equally important to determine whether the magnet should only capture the part, position it precisely, hold it long-term, or also release it safely. In some applications, a strong magnet is an advantage, while in others it is more of a problem. If fast removal of the part by a robot or operator is required, excessive adhesion prolongs the cycle and increases the risk of damage.

The Selection of Magnetic Material Is Not Only a Question of Force

In practice, neodymium magnets are often chosen automatically. The reason is clear – at small dimensions, they provide high magnetic induction and significant holding force. However, this does not mean that they are the most suitable for every solution. If the application operates at higher temperature, in a corrosive environment, or with a requirement for long-term stability under specific conditions, ferrite, SmCo, or AlNiCo magnets may also be more suitable.

Ferrite is larger in size at the same effect, but it is durable, economically reasonable, and fully sufficient in many separation or fixation tasks. SmCo has an advantage at higher temperatures and where higher chemical resistance is required. AlNiCo has specific properties used in measuring technology or wherever a particular magnetic behavior is important, not only maximum force.

It is therefore worth starting with the question of what the operating limits are, not which magnet is the “strongest”. Force without context is only a marketing parameter. In a technical application, the usable force at the real operating point is what matters.

The Magnetic Circuit Also Matters

The magnet itself is only part of the solution. The steel housing, pole pieces, magnetic field shielding, and the way the magnetic circuit is closed have a major influence. A well-designed magnetic system can concentrate the flux where it is needed, reduce losses, and increase repeatability. Conversely, unsuitable placement of the magnet within the structure can significantly reduce the effect, even with high-quality material.

This is a common reason why two seemingly identical magnets behave differently in two devices. It is not a contradiction in the parameters, but a different design of the magnetic circuit and working gap.

Working Gap, Surface, and Counterpart Material

The biggest difference between theory and reality is often the air gap. Every gap between the magnet and the attracted part dramatically reduces the effect. It may be paint, galvanizing, dirt, surface unevenness, protective film, or simply manufacturing tolerance. If the application works only with a zero gap, it will be unreliable in production.

The counterpart material is equally important. Low-carbon steel reacts differently from hardened material, perforated sheet metal, or a thin-walled part. With thin materials, the magnetic flux does not close optimally and the declared holding force is often unattainable. If the part is small, segmented, or has sharp transitions, contact is usually not full-surface and the result is weaker than the catalog would suggest.

At this stage, a simple rule helps – never design according to an ideal laboratory value. An operating design should account for a reserve and the real condition of the surface after a certain period of use.

Temperature, Environment, and Application Lifetime

Temperature is one of the most underestimated inputs. Every permanent magnet has a temperature limit at which its properties begin to change. Sometimes this is a temporary performance drop; other times it is permanent demagnetization. This is critical near furnaces, motors, welding workplaces, or wherever the device heats up cyclically.

Corrosion is also a risk. Neodymium magnets in particular require suitable surface protection and a structural solution that limits coating damage. If the magnet is used in humidity, an aggressive environment, or outdoors, it is not enough to monitor only magnetic parameters. The overall resistance of the assembly is important.

In dynamic applications, mechanical brittleness must also be considered. A strong magnet does not necessarily have mechanical toughness. Impact, clamping two magnets together, or inaccurate contact can lead to chipped edges or complete cracking. The design therefore often requires not only the correct material, but also a housing, stops, or controlled motion guidance.

The Safety Reserve Must Be Based on Operation

In handling and lifting applications, it is not enough to work with nominal force. A clearly defined safety reserve is required according to the type of load and risk. If the application involves a load, movement above operators, or automated handling, the design must be assessed much more strictly than with a simple fixation function.

It is important to distinguish whether the magnet carries the entire load or only assists mechanical guidance. In many cases, the correct solution is a combination of magnetic and mechanical function. The magnet helps position or hold the part, but safety is ensured by a stop, latch, guide surface, or another mechanical element. Such a design is usually more resistant to dirt, wear, and changing conditions.

If the application is sensitive to failure, it is also worth considering the service scenario. Can the magnet be replaced easily? Can its condition be checked? Is a performance drop recognizable before it causes a problem in production? A good application is not only functional at startup, but also sustainable in operation.

Prototype and Testing Are Part of the Design, Not a Final Formality

Even with an experienced design, a magnetic application remains an area where sample verification is worthwhile. Calculations and catalog data are the foundation, but the real part, actual surface, and specific working cycle show the behavior more accurately. This applies especially to separation, part feeding, clamping thin sheets, and automated handling.

The prototype should not only confirm that “it holds”. It should also show the limits of the solution. When the force begins to drop, how the system reacts to contamination, what lateral stress does, and how pull-off force changes after hundreds of cycles. These data determine whether the application becomes a reliable part of production.

In technical practice, it often turns out that a small change in geometry brings more than replacing the magnet with a stronger one. Shifting the contact surface, changing the thickness of the steel part, reducing the gap, or adding mechanical guidance can fundamentally improve the result with lower costs and lower risk.

When Consultation Is Worthwhile in the Design of a Magnetic Application

If the application is related to safety, high temperature, automation, separation in the production flow, or a non-standard part, technical consultation saves time and incorrect iterations. In such cases, it is no longer just about selecting a product from stock, but about designing a functional whole. An experienced supplier can identify the weak point before it appears during production startup.

This is the difference between buying a magnet and designing a magnetic application. For a simple office or presentation task, choosing a suitable type is enough. In industry, however, the magnetic circuit, tolerance, service, safety, and long-term stability come into play. That is why, for more demanding solutions, it is worth working with a partner who understands not only the product range but also operation. SELOS Magnety is built precisely on this combination – technical knowledge, available solutions, and the ability to verify what will work beyond the catalog.

If a magnetic application is expected to work reliably, do not start with the question of which magnet to buy, but with what exactly the system must handle even on a worse-than-ideal day of operation.